Rock Valley College Athletics

During her two years at Rock Valley College, Keefe achieved extraordinary success both on the field and in the classroom. She maintained a formidable .462 batting average, crushed seven home runs, and drove in an impressive 112 runs. Her exceptional talent earned her numerous accolades, including Academic All-American honors, two-time NJCAA All-American recognition, two-time NFCA All-American honors, two-time All-Region, and All-Conference selections. Keefe was also a two-time member of the National All-Tournament team, was named a Marucci Elite Hitter, and was a consistent presence on the Dean’s list (2014-2015).
Keefe continued her decorated athletic and academic journey at NCAA Division II University of Montevallo. There, she continued to excel academically, earning a place as a Silver Scholar on the Peach Belt Conference Presidential Honor Roll and receiving the NCAA Division II Athletics Directors Association (D2ADA) Academic Achievement Award.
Kaytee graduated from Montevallo in 2018 with a Bachelor of Arts in Elementary Education and furthered her education by earning a Master’s Degree in Curriculum and Instruction in 2025.
Today, Kaytee channels her leadership and dedication into the classroom, teaching fourth grade at Hillcrest Elementary School in Antioch, Illinois. She married Russell Coulter in 2023 and is the daughter of Kelly and Mike Keefe.